It’s time to share my go-to Thrive Market Paleo essentials. Since I first wrote about my Whole30 staples from Thrive Market, I’ve continued to save significantly over the past two years using the healthy food delivery service. Over that time I’ve saved hundreds of dollars and regularly get asked what I order most. The short answer: nearly everything non-perishable and pantry-related I would otherwise buy at the grocery store—nuts, canned goods, flours, oils, spices, condiments and a lot more. Below is a clearer look at the Paleo items I consistently buy from Thrive Market and why they’re worth considering for your pantry.
Many of the Paleo picks below are also Whole30-friendly: bulk nuts, grain-free flours, bars, nut-based creamers, canned goods, cooking oils, sauces, and vinegars. Thrive Market sorts products by dietary preference—Paleo, gluten-free, vegetarian—and by category, making it straightforward to find items that meet your needs.
Here’s a snapshot of how Thrive Market works and why I use it: it’s a membership-based online marketplace for natural and specialty foods, household items, and personal care products, often priced lower than typical retail. The annual membership fee offsets quickly if you buy pantry staples in bulk and take advantage of sales. They also run regular promotions that add free items to your cart with qualifying orders, and those offers often include things I use frequently—like coconut oil, nutpods, coconut aminos and snack bars—so I sometimes wait for a special before placing a large order.
My most-purchased items here are those I use constantly in Paleo cooking. Vinegars (apple cider and balsamic) and coconut aminos are noticeably cheaper, and that matters when you go through multiple bottles during a Whole30 or in everyday cooking. Large bottles of apple cider vinegar and bulk cooking oils are particularly cost-effective. I use these for dressings, marinades and general cooking, so buying them at lower prices saved me a lot over time.
Ghee is another staple I buy through Thrive Market—both the store brand and Organic Valley varieties are routinely cheaper than retail. Grain-free flours and baking mixes often come with meaningful savings, and canned goods like crushed tomatoes, diced tomatoes and marinara are frequently priced far below in-store alternatives. For items I use regularly—canned tomato products, coconut milk, coconut cream—buying from Thrive Market keeps pantry costs down.
Snack and convenience items are worth mentioning too. Simple Mills Paleo cookies, crackers and pancake mixes are less expensive there, and Siete grain-free tortilla chips are usually a good deal compared to local stores. Meat sticks and jerky from brands like The New Primal and convenient bars like Lara Bars are often much cheaper in multi-pack options on Thrive Market, which makes stocking up easier and more affordable.
Bulk nuts and seeds are a major win for me: Thrive Market’s large bags of almonds, cashews, walnuts, pistachios and mixed nuts are typically 30–45% less expensive than comparable store prices. That’s a significant per-bag savings when you use nuts for snacking, baking, making nut milks or adding to salads. I also buy shredded coconut, MCT oil, collagen and protein powders, nut butters, tuna and bone broth there. Spices and bulk seasonings are another area where I saved by buying larger quantities and making my own blends at home.
Because Thrive Market offers different brands for many items, I compare sizes and prices within the site to pick the best value for what I use most. They often have larger jarred or bulk formats—like a 24-ounce jar of applesauce made from just organic apples—that make it simple to stock up without overpaying.
Overall, Thrive Market has been a worthwhile resource for my Paleo pantry. If you care about convenience, want to avoid overpaying for specialty items, or like the idea of buying staples in bulk, it’s worth trying a membership or free trial to see if it fits your habits. For me, it’s made household meal prep easier and saved money on the ingredients I rely on most.
This post may contain affiliate links. The products mentioned are ones I use personally and recommend. Purchases made through affiliate links cost you nothing extra and help support this blog financially. Thank you for your support.